Top 10 Worst Premier League Players in History

Top 10 Worst Premier League Players in History

Who are the Top 10 Worst Premier League Players in History? Have you ever thought of finding out which players are the worst to ever play in the Premier League? Well if you have then worry not because we have prepared a list of the Top 10 Worst Premier League Players in History.

There are a number of reasons some players are considered to be the worst, some because of the aggression and brutality towards the game, some because they can’t find the back of the net or have no idea on how to defend and they are busy getting hefty wages for being not good. Watch & Bet on Football =>

Worst Premier League Players of All Time

While our top 10 list covers the most infamous names, other publications have ranked the worst ever slightly differently.

According to Silly Seasom, the all-time worst Premier League players include:

Other notable names frequently mentioned include Eric Djemba-Djemba (Manchester United), Christian Poulsen (Liverpool), and Kostas Mitroglou (Fulham) all of whom arrived with big reputations and departed with barely a whimper. Watch & Bet on Football =>

Worst Player in Premier League 2026

The 2025/26 Premier League season has produced its own share of underperformers.

The bottom five (ranked 15-11):

Rodrigo Gomes (Wolves) – 6.43 rating

Lukas Nmecha (Leeds) – 6.42 rating

Hwang Hee-chan (Wolves) – 6.41 rating

Jean-Ricner Bellegarde (Wolves) – 6.40 rating

Callum Wilson (West Ham) – 6.40 rating

Anthony Elanga—signed by Newcastle United for £55 million after a stellar season at Nottingham Forest proved to be one of the worst signings of the season, failing to score a single goal and registering just one assist in 32 matches.

Liam Delap at Chelsea has been another major disappointment. Signed for €40 million from Ipswich, he scored just two goals in 41 appearances across all competitions. Chelsea fans reportedly viewed his presence on the pitch as a sign that goal-scoring hopes were over.

Alexander Isak at Liverpool—a record €140 million signing managed only three league goals while constantly plagued by injuries, leading Gary Neville to label him the most disappointing player in the league.

Perhaps the lowest-rated player of the season was Tyrick Mitchell, who recorded a dismal 6.18 average rating.

Worst Premier League Players Currently

Looking at the current crop of underperformers in the 2025/26 season, several players stand out as statistically the worst in the league right now:

Viktor Gyokeres (Arsenal) has been statistically one of the worst players in the Premier League, losing possession 42.7% of the time he touches the ball the worst rate in the entire league.

Guglielmo Vicario (Tottenham) has been a defensive liability, recording the league’s worst -5.5 goals prevented compared to expected goals conceded. His ball-playing ability has been heavily criticised, and he has been described as “awful at defending set-pieces”.

Alisson Becker (Liverpool)—once considered the world’s best goalkeeper has statistically been the worst goalkeeper in the Premier League this season according to data from The Daily Mail.

Thierno Barry (Everton) didn’t register a single shot on target until his 14th appearance for the club and only scored his first goal on matchday 15.

Liam Delap (Chelsea), Anthony Elanga (Newcastle), and Xavi Simons (Tottenham) have all been named among the biggest flops of the current campaign. Watch & Bet on Football =>

Top Ten Worst Players in the Premier League History

Previously we published the Top 10 Worst Footballers Ever &Top 10 Worst Goal Keeping Mistakes Of All Time! if you haven’t seen these make sure you do after this list.

Being one of the worst players could have been as a result of VIDEO: The Worst Open Goal Misses In Football Ever!, Top 10 Worst Fights To Happen In Football & Top 10 Worst Injuries to Happen in Football!.

Now let’s find out the Top 10 Worst Premier League Players in History.

10. Winston Bogarde- Chelsea

Kick starting the list of the Top 10 Worst Premier League Players in History is former Chelsea man Winston Bogarde. Winston Bogarde is currently retired from professional  football but today he makes the list of the Top 10 Worst Premier League Players in History. 

A player who was known for his physical strength, he is most remembered for his times at Ajax, Barcelona and Chelsea football club, in his last three seasons at Chelsea football club he failed to make a single appearance for the Blues, the club wanted to sell the player due to his hefty salary and was not helping the team in any way but he chose to stay and take the high wages regardless. Watch & Bet on Football =>

9. Savio Nsereko – West Ham United

Savio Nsereko takes up ninth on the list of the Top 10 Worst Premier League Players in History. After signing for the Hammers in 2009 for a fee around £9 million he signed a four and a half year contract at West Ham United.

He was also given the jersey number 10. Savio barely lasted a year in the Premier League as he failed to settle at the club and later in the year he joined Fiorentina for a fee of €2.7 million with Manuel de Costa joining West Ham United as part of the deal. Watch & Bet on Football =>

8. Ahmed Fathi- Sheffield United

The Egyptian international Ahmed Fathi makes the list of the Top 10 Worst Premier League Players in History coming in at number eight. The 31 year old plays as a right-back or a defensive midfielder and is currently playing for Al Ahly in the Egyptian Premier League. Wow! From the Premier League to the Egyptian League? Damn! He has gone so low.

He played in the Premier League for Sheffield United when they were trying to get off the relegation game he only played three games for United in the quest for escaping the relegation zone. But a few months later he was released by the team and went back to Egypt were he is currently playing.

7. Corrado Grabbi- Blackburn Rovers

Taking up seventh is ex Blackburn Rovers player Corrado Grabbi. Back in 2001 Corrado Grabbi signed for Blackburn Rovers for £6.75 million and became the most expensive signing by the club at the time.

He played a total of 30 games in three years for the Rovers but only managed to score two goals for the Premier League. This was not good enough for a striker and after the failed spell in the Premier League he returned to his home country Italy were he ended his career in 2008.

6. Xisco- Newcastle United

In sixth is Spanish player Xisco who is currently playing for Mallorca on loan from Cordoba. At the age of 21, Xisco joined Newcastle from Deportivo La Coruna for a fee of  £5.7 million, a fee which could have seen risen to £7 million according to the agreement. Watch & Bet on Football =>

The player was so horrible on the pitch as he found himself seventh choice to  Michael Owen, Obafemi Martins, Mark Viduka, Peter Løvenkrands, Shola Ameobi and Andy Carroll. 

The club tried to get rid of him but couldn’t work because of FIFA rules that a player cannot play for three different clubs in the year, Newcastle was later relegated from the Premier League and were stuck with the Spanish international for five more years.

The player only managed to make just nine games and managed to write his name into the Newcastle record books by scoring a goal before finallly moving back to Spain.

5. Per Kroldrup- Everton

Closing down on the top five is former Everton man Per Kroldrup. Everton signed Danish center-back Per Kroldrup for five million pounds from Italian club Udinese, when he arrived at the club he couldn’t start playing yet as he was out due to injury.

When he was fit again he played a full ninety minutes for the Merseyside reds and were beaten 4-0 and the Danish never played for the Toffees ever again till he moved back to Italy as he was sold to Fiorentina.

This player might have flopped in the Premier League but he managed to rack up 33 caps for the Danish national team. Watch & Bet on Football =>

4. Roque Junior-Leeds United

Roque Junior is a former footballer who played as a center-back during his playing days, he also won the FIFA World Cup with Brazil in 2002, he was later signed on loan by Leeds after his triumph with the Brazilian national team but his Premier League career only lasted seven games as Leeds United found out that the Brazilian was so poor at defending and was sent back to Milan were he later joined Siena on loan again in the same year.

3. Andrea Silenzi-Nottingham Forest

Closing down on the top three is Italian ex footballer Andrea Silenzi. The Italian joined Nottingham Forest in 1995 and became the first Italian player to play in the Premier League.

He had a decent scoring record in Italy as he managed to score 32 goals in 132 appearances playing for four clubs, Nottingham Forest thought they would gamble on the player and what a gamble it was by the Premier League club to bring the Italian in the League. Andrea Silenzi was definitely the worst player to represent the league by that time.

After leaving the Premier League he only managed to find the back of the net nine times in the rest of his career playing for four different clubs. Watch & Bet on Football =>

2. Ali Dia- Southampton

Taking up second on the list is Ali Dia who played for Southampton in the Premier League, Rumor has it that Ali Dia’s friend called Southampton pretending to be George Weah and advised them to sign his cousin Ali Dia’s, and he was later signed and was allowed to train with the team, Ali signed a month long contract with the Saint’s.

He came in as substitute against Leeds but only played for 53 minutes before pulling , he was later released after just 14 days as a Saints player, Wow! That was quick!. Watch & Bet on Football =>

1. Amaury Bischoff- Arsenal

Amaury Bischoff was signed by Arsenal’s Arsene Wenger in 2008 from German side Werder Bremen even as Arsene Wenger signed this player he knew it was a gamble of talent. He knew the player’s injury record over the years.

On 2nd May 2009 Amaury Bischoff made his first and only Premier League appearance for the Gunners as he came on as a second half sub as he replaced Theo Walcott his time in the Premier League only lasted 28 minutes he was later released by the club and is now playing for Preußen Münster as a central midfielder. Watch & Bet on Football =>

See also: 

• Top 10 most gifted full-backs of all time!
• Top 10: Jose Mourinho’s Worst Signings ever
• Premier League Player Salaries 2026 (Highest Paid)
• Top 10 Players who have been relegated from the Premier League!